1.5M ratings
277k ratings

See, that’s what the app is perfect for.

Sounds perfect Wahhhh, I don’t wanna

Some people have questioned the term “sneer culture”. I don’t have any particular thoughts as it relates to HPMOR, but this seems to me to be a real natural kind.

Quick definition by extension:
Frequent gathering places: Something Awful, RationalWiki, Gawker, Freethought Blogs
Favorite words: gross, man-child, entitled
Favorite targets: bronies, furries, paleo dieters, Christians, Objectivists, anti-vaxxers, Tumblrinas
Favorite accusations: person lives in their parents’ basement, person is overweight, person is a virgin, person is an MRA or “fedora”, person believes woo or is a “denialist”, person is a “special snowflake”.

Quick definition by intension:
The apex predators of the signaling world, at least in Blue-coded spaces. People who have optimized for always being on the right side of a lynch mob.  People who really enjoy punching down at non-conformists, and trying to invoke people’s Disgust foundation to urge them to treat such non-conformists lower than dirt.

A powerful combination of mocking anybody more social-justicey than normal as a special snowflake otherkin Tumblrina, and mocking anybody less social-justicey than normal as a disgusting MRA PUA racist creep, while themselves making sure to be exactly the most popular amount of social-justicey at all times.

Favorite attack is to take a person, focus on the single most unpopular thing they’ve ever said, remove it from context, and use it as the only thing they ever say about a person, ie “Did you see that Slate Star Codex post?” “Slate Star Codex? That’s by the guy who said [the single thing I have ever stated that would be most damaging out of contex]!”

Advanced version of this attack is to take a complicated non-mainstream idea, focus on its worst and most extreme practitioners, link it however tenuously to things that are known to be taboo and gross, then declare that the thing itself is taboo and gross, and declare anyone who says it’s more complicated to be a fellow-traveler who should themselves be considered taboo and gross. Example: “He believes in cryonics, which is popular in libertarian circles, but some libertarians become neoreactionaries, and some neoreactionaries are MRAs. So basically if you believe in cryonics you’re an entitled fedora! M'lady!”

The problem is that these people are right 90% of the time, because usually the strongest position to mock people from is the popular consensus position, and when consensuses and small fringe groups clash, the consensus is usually right. And when it’s not right, most people don’t realize that it’s not right and so you can’t call them on it. This makes sneerers really hard to call out and get rid of.

I don’t know if this is exactly what Eliezer means when he says “sneer culture”, but it’s how I think of it and it’s something that sure as heck needs a name.